Aug 11, Foul!
Education The traditional orgy of college football games that occurs every Thanksgiving has recently shared the stage with a new tradition: With increasing frequency and urgency, critics contend that the millions of dollars that colleges and universities are receiving as a result of big-time sports come with the moral cost of exploiting young men.
In many ways, this description is sadly accurate. The players are now encouraged to become ever larger, with offensive lines averaging over pounds per player, no matter how unhealthy it is for young bodies and hearts to try to carry that unneeded weight.
Injuries, which have always been a serious problem, seem to have become even worse than ever before. Twenty-year-old men are suffering career-ending injuries, and like their heroes in the National Football League, many of them are also facing futures with debilitating brain damage from repeated concussive hits to the head.
There is much that should be done, both in terms of better protecting players, and providing adequate health care and disability insurance coverage to those unfortunate young men who give their all and are never heard from again. Seeing the eye-popping size of television contracts to broadcast college football games, many people understandably wonder why the players are not sharing in the bounty.
The problem is that the standard story is based on a gross distortion of reality. College football players do receive high compensation, and they would probably do worse under a wage-paying system. The reason that people often dismiss the idea that players are paid is that the payment comes in the form of athletic scholarships.
The cynical view is that this payment is not real, with players being deprived of the education that schools pretend to offer them. Although there is some limited truth to that charge, however, the overall reality is different, and much more nuanced.
In addition, however, there is a distinct whiff of anti-intellectualism in the claim that free tuition and fees, as well as free room and board at an institution of higher learning, are somehow no big deal.
In his passion and zeal, Bilas willfully distorts the reality of college athletics. The ESPN networks employ many analysts who are known for their enlightened views. Even Ley, however, could not stop himself from offering a notably cynical comment in a program over Thanksgiving weekend, saying that everyone in college sports is getting paid—except, of course, the players themselves!
The sarcasm was thick in his voice. That these critics repeatedly make this mistake, therefore, calls out for an explanation. Perhaps their claim is that the amount of money involved here is too paltry to matter. How much in cash-equivalent compensation are we talking about?
The top competitive division of the NCAA allows universities to offer up to 85 full-ride football scholarships at any time. Duke University, where Mr. How many American families would view that as small potatoes?
Moreover, the value of what the players are receiving can be measured not only in terms of how much they would otherwise have to pay, but also in how much their lifetime earnings are increased by going to college. If a student can attend college for free, of course, then the rate of return is infinite.
As a starting point, therefore, we can say that athletes who graduate from their universities put themselves in line to receive a half-million dollars over the remainder of their working lives, on average, without paying a dime in tuition.
But surely we must take into account the reality that college football players often do not graduate, and are sometimes not asked to do college-level work. In a Verdict column I wrote early last year, I accepted uncritically the idea that colleges fail to educate their athletes, by forcing them to divert energy from studying to, instead, practicing and playing football.
At best, this is a gross generalization, and it hides the benefits of even an uncompleted college degree. How many football players actually graduate?
The NCAA claims that athletes graduate at higher rates than the student body as a whole, but some researchers question this claim.
Using one of several measures of graduation rates, one skeptical study found that college football players had a Even if the rate among football players is lower than other students, therefore, no one can claim that the rate is anything like zero. At least two-thirds of football players graduate within six years, and they do so without laying out any money.
How many people are in this dropout category? For most people, dropping out is a financial necessity, which is exactly the grim decision that college football players are spared by receiving full rides. Perhaps, however, college football players are receiving an inferior educational product from their institutions.
Certainly, there are academic scandals centering on college athletes occurring with depressing frequency, and there is reason to be concerned that players are pushed into less demanding majors. The efforts to eliminate such scandalous behavior should surely continue, but paying college athletes will certainly do nothing to improve that situation—and it is, if anything, likely to allow people to satisfy themselves with the idea that we no longer need to worry about educating the wage laborers who are toiling on the practice fields.
There is, however, no denying that having gone to college, especially if it resulted in receiving an actual degree, has value—not only economic value, but value in shaping a citizen and a human being. For many jobs, a college degree is the threshold requirement, and former football players are thus able to apply for jobs that they never would have been able even to consider otherwise.
They also are often known to in-state employers, who are eager to hire former local stars.To increase the efficiency of payments to college players, universities should pay them directly. If schools feel that student-athletes shouldn’t be paid while they’re in school, the funds could be held until after college — maybe even paying a bonus for those who graduate.
College athletes do so much for universities like Kennesaw State, and the least schools can do is to pay them back for their hard work and dedication.
Last year, revenue for the National Collegiate Athletic Association surpassed $1 billion, making the organization one of . Do you think you deserve payment? Thesis Statement I believe college athletes should not be paid for playing.
There are over 13, college football players in the country while there is only about 1, in the NFL Imagine paying all of those players salaries including the .
All college athletes deserve a fair shot. We focus on respect, integrity and responsibility, both on and off the field, so that college sports prepare student-athletes for life. Grant Hill, former basketball player at Duke and current recipient of the NCAA President's Gerald R.
Ford Award. College Athletes Deserve Pay College Athletes spend 40 hours or more per week on their sport; with this being said college athletes deserve to be paid. The payment should be helped out by the government. If the process is athletes spending more time on their sport rather than their education, something is going to have to change.
|Who can edit:||Should College Athletes Be Paid?|
|Related Posts||With current television revenue resulting from NCAA football bowl games and March Madness in basketball, there is now a clamoring for compensating both football and basketball players beyond that of an athletic scholarship. Dennis Johnson follows with a counterpoint making the case that athletes in these sports should receive compensation beyond that of a college scholarship and forwards five proposals to pay the athletes.|
|College Athletes Deserve Pay by Daniel - Letters to the Next President||Ryan Jeanes It is time for university officials to start paying student athletes.|
|Pay to play: College athletes deserve compensation||Pro I believe that the top recruited college athletes should be paid based on their performance.|
|Downloading prezi...||One critical issue, among a plethora of disagreements between the two sides, is should athletes be paid for playing sports in college?|
Feb 02, · The NCAA is a pipeline for certain athletes to the NBA and NFL and a money-maker for schools. It's time for colleges to pay student athletes.